Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts FY 2007

			Denial Rate
Immigration Court	Judge	Decisions	% Grants	% Denials
Arlington	Malphrus, Garry D.	263	50.2	49.8
	Snow, Thomas G.	598	66.6	33.4
	Iskra, Wayne R.	668	67.1	32.9
	Crosland, David W.	222	71.2	28.8
	O'Leary, Brian M.	237	72.2	27.8
	Burman, Lawrence O.	437	74.1	25.9
	Bryant, John Milo	505	80.4	19.6
	Schmidt, Paul W.	493	83.8	16.2
Atlanta	Cassidy, William A.	114	7.9	92.1
	Wilson, Earle B.	211	9	91
	Sease, Grace A.	185	14.1	85.9
	Pelletier, Jonathan D.	424	14.6	85.4
	Houser, Wayne K., Jr.	299	33.4	66.6
Baltimore	Barrett, Bruce M.	286	31.1	68.9
	DuFresne, Jill H.	374	44.9	55.1
	Gossart, John F., Jr.	742	51.5	48.5
	Dornell, Lisa	757	53	47
	Williams, Phillip T.	640	54.8	45.2
	Kessler, Elizabeth A.	710	57.7	42.3
	Crosland, David W.	297	64.6	35.4
Bloomington	Nickerson, William J., Jr.	197	14.2	85.8
	Conley de Castro, Susan E.	123	21.1	78.9
	Olmanson, Kristin W.	505	25	75
	Dierkes, Joseph R.	220	30	70
Boston	Cramer, Francis L.	361	41	59
	Shapiro, Leonard I.	549	41	59
	Feder, Robin E.	691	42.8	57.2
	O'Malley, Brenda M.	301	48.8	51.2
	Klein, Eliza C.	607	49.6	50.4
	Gagnon, Paul M.	491	52.5	47.5
	D'Angelo, Matthew J.	374	56.1	43.9
Buffalo	Reid, John B.	200	12	88
	Montante, Philip J., Jr	239	16.7	83.3
Charlotte	Pettinato, Barry J.	225	12.9	87.1
	Couch, V. Stuart	145	28.3	71.7
	Holmes-Simmons, Theresa	223	41.7	58.3
Chicago	Vinikoor, Robert D.	637	43	57
	Cuevas, Carlos	489	50.1	49.9
	Zerbe, Craig M.	564	54.1	45.9
	Perez-Guzman, Virginia	172	58.1	41.9
	Giambastiani, Jennie L.	400	67	33
	Bower, Glen L.	259	83.4	16.6
Cleveland	Janas, Thomas	364	18.1	81.9
	Evans, D. William, Jr.	683	18.6	81.4
	Snow, Thomas G.	190	20	80
	Romig, Jeffrey L.	108	27.8	72.2
	Brown, Alison M.	256	47.7	52.3
	Harris, Rodger C.	168	50	50
	Bryant, John Milo	143	75.5	24.5
Dallas	Sims, Deitrich H.	121	16.5	83.5
	Ozmun, Richard R.	198	28.3	71.7
	Baird, Michael P.	122	33.6	66.4
Denver	Vandello, James P.	139	7.9	92.1
	Cordova, David J.	428	35.5	64.5
	Livingston, Donn L.	537	38.7	61.3
Detroit	Nettles, Marsha K.	407	29.7	70.3
	Hacker, Elizabeth A.	494	36	64
	Newberry, Robert D.	550	36.9	63.1
El Paso	Roepke, Thomas C.	161	3.7	96.3
	Abbott, William L.	186	19.9	80.1
Elizabeth	Tadal, Mirlande	387	20.7	79.3
	Harbeck, Dorothy A.	389	42.7	57.3
Eloy	DeVitto, James Alan	131	6.9	93.1
	Spencer-Walters, Linda Inez	113	7.1	92.9
Florence	Taylor, Bruce A.	227	9.7	90.3
	Jefferies, Scott M.	195	13.3	86.7
Guaynabo	Lopez-Defillo, Irma	109	11	89
Hagatna	Beamer, Dayna M.	142	58.5	41.5
Harlingen	Ayala, David	162	43.2	56.8
Hartford	Straus, Michael W.	709	30.2	69.8
	Verrillo, Philip	158	57	43
Honolulu	Wagner, Clarence M., Jr.	101	38.6	61.4
	Beamer, Dayna M.	644	69.4	30.6
Houston	Law, Philip S.	423	18.9	81.1
	Yam, Mimi Schooley	115	19.1	80.9
	Brisack, Chris A.	417	19.2	80.8
	Zimmer, William K.	359	27	73
	Rankin Yates, Clarease Rankin	285	29.8	70.2
Houston - Detained	Rose, Howard	222	0	100
	Benton, Jimmie L.	199	12.6	87.4
Imperial	Staton, Jack W.	267	18.4	81.6
	James, Dennis R.	120	33.3	66.7
Kansas City	O'Malley, John R.	196	26.5	73.5
	Davis, Paula V.	199	36.2	63.8
Lancaster	Vicars, Robert O., Jr.	127	24.4	75.6
	Burke, David H.	152	25.7	74.3
	Laurent, Scott D.	124	29	71
Las Vegas	Romig, Jeffrey L.	134	23.9	76.1
	Mullins, Ronald L.	188	28.2	71.8
	Gastley, Harry L.	267	33.7	66.3
	Weiss, Irene	197	62.9	37.1
Los Angeles	Munoz, Lorraine J.	723	12.2	87.8
	Riley, Kevin W.	211	20.4	79.6
	Giattina, Anthony T.	494	20.6	79.4
	Bither, Christine A.	505	24.6	75.4
	Naselow-Nahas, Tara	258	27.5	72.5
	Tabaddor, Afsaneh Ashley	652	32.4	67.6
	Latimore, Jan D.	474	32.5	67.5
	O'Connor, Lee A.	191	34	66
	Walton, Richard D.	516	35.9	64.1
	Dunkel-Bradley, Dorothy A.	573	36.1	63.9
	Walsh, John F.	697	36.4	63.6
	Parchert, Brett M.	369	36.9	63.1
	Travieso, Frank M.	461	38	62
	Bank, Ira E.	616	38.3	61.7
	Ho, Anna	413	38.3	61.7
	Rodriguez de Jongh, Lourdes A.	123	39.8	60.2
	Rooyani, Rodin	265	40	60
	Bronzina, Isabel A.	289	40.1	59.9
	Daw, Alison E.	282	40.1	59.9
	Little, Monica M.	211	40.8	59.2
	Renner, Renee L.	117	41	59
	Stancill, Christine E.	797	41.4	58.6
	DiMarzio, Philip L.	223	43	57
	Bass, Lori R.	289	44.3	55.7
	Tsankov, Mimi	338	44.4	55.6
	Anderson, David C.	527	44.6	55.4
	Peters, Rose C.	413	46.5	53.5
	Gembacz, Gilbert T.	106	47.2	52.8
	Sitgraves, Darcy D.	403	50.6	49.4
	Fong, Thomas Y. K.	157	52.2	47.8
	Costa, Philip J.	176	55.1	44.9
	Martin, William J., Jr	155	55.5	44.5
	Vahid-Tehrani, Gita	587	58.1	41.9
	Sholomson, Stephen L.	438	60.5	39.5
	Neumeister, David	139	62.6	37.4
	Bakke Varzandeh, Joyce A.	175	63.4	36.6
	O'Sullivan, Maureen S.	230	67.4	32.6
Los Fresnos	Achtsam, Howard E.	124	25.8	74.2
	Hunsucker, Keith E.	151	29.8	70.2
	Powell, Robert L.	131	35.9	64.1
Memphis	Pazar, Charles E.	891	43.9	56.1
	Holt, Rebecca L.	269	59.1	40.9
	Burman, Lawrence O.	567	64.7	35.3
Miami	Metcalf, Mark H.	283	9.9	90.1
	Opaciuch, Adam	452	11.5	88.5
	Hanson, Mahlon F.	496	12.9	87.1
	Wilson, Earle B.	210	14.8	85.2
	Lopez-Enriquez, Maria M.	199	15.6	84.4
	Holliday, Carey R.	791	16.3	83.7
	Marks Lane, Denise A.	592	18.1	81.9
	Harris, Rodger C.	377	18.8	81.2
	Martinez-Esquivel, Lourdes	237	19	81
	Chapa, Teofilo	397	22.9	77.1
	Torreh-Bayouth, Lilliana	970	23.9	76.1
	Sanders, Charles J.	485	24.5	75.5
	Bradley, Kevin G.	338	25.1	74.9
	Mateo, Rene D.	143	25.2	74.8
	Alexander, Scott G.	665	25.7	74.3
	Crosland, David W.	315	25.7	74.3
	Opaciuch, John	470	26	74
	Sukkar, Elisa M.	355	28.2	71.8
	McCormack, Nancy R.	522	28.4	71.6
	Dowell, J. Daniel	580	30.5	69.5
	Solow, Bruce W.	859	33.3	66.7
	Horn, Michael C.	473	34.7	65.3
	Mander, Stephen E.	665	36.4	63.6
	Miranda, Pedro A.	685	38.7	61.3
Miami - Krome	Opaciuch, Adam	245	1.6	98.4
	Hurewitz, Kenneth S.	435	3	97
	Ford, Rex J.	501	6.6	93.4
	Slavin, Denise N.	259	13.5	86.5
New Orleans	Stogner, William Wayne	408	31.4	68.6
New York	Vomacka, Alan A.	659	33.4	66.6
	Hom, Sandy K.	1279	39	61
	Nelson, Barbara A.	1291	39.8	60.2
	Abrams, Steven R.	640	41.4	58.6
	Defonzo, Paul A.	444	53.6	46.4
	Videla, Gabriel C.	758	55.9	44.1
	Cheng, Mary M.	597	63.5	36.5
	Christensen, Jesse B.	528	64.4	35.6
	Ferris, Noel Anne	491	64.8	35.2
	Wright, Virna A.	350	65.7	34.3
	Balasquide, Javier E.	1641	70.1	29.9
	Chase, Jeffrey S.	125	72	28
	Poczter, Aviva L.	386	72	28
	Rohan, Patricia A.	1548	74.2	25.8
	Weisel, Robert D.	1358	75	25
	Burr, Sarah M.	658	77.1	22.9
	Zagzoug, Randa	386	77.7	22.3
	Chew, George T.	2086	79.1	20.9
	Bukszpan, Joanna M.	1307	79.5	20.5
	Elstein, Annette S.	1061	79.6	20.4
	Schoppert, Douglas B.	1425	79.8	20.2
	Morace, Philip L.	2277	80	20
	Mulligan, Thomas J.	1774	81.5	18.5
	Segal, Alice	470	82.3	17.7
	Sichel, Helen J.	1651	82.6	17.4
	Gordon-Uruakpa, Vivienne E.	1741	83.6	16.4
	Laforest, Brigitte	1903	85.5	14.5
	Van Wyke, William Van	1508	86.2	13.8
	McManus, Margaret	1915	86.7	13.3
	Holmes-Simmons, Theresa	524	87	13
	Brennan, Noel A.	2078	90.4	9.6
	Lamb, Elizabeth A.	1504	93	7
	Loprest, F. James, Jr.	403	93.1	6.9
	Bain, Terry A.	2042	94.8	5.2
New York - DET	Vomacka, Alan A.	189	7.9	92.1
	Page, Alan L.	144	24.3	75.7
	Abrams, Steven R.	170	30	70
Newark	Reichenberg, Margaret R.	435	20.7	79.3
	Roy, Susan Girardo	170	28.2	71.8
	Dogin, Henry S.	373	32.4	67.6
	Pugliese, Eugene	447	34.9	65.1
	Leeds, Frederic G.	491	49.3	50.7
	Garcy, Annie S.	707	55.2	44.8
	Riefkohl, Alberto J.	660	59.2	40.8
	Khan, Amiena	114	78.1	21.9
Omaha	Morris, Daniel A.	294	11.6	88.4
	Anderson, Jack L.	304	20.4	79.6
	Fujimoto, James R.	552	21.2	78.8
Orlando	Wilson, Earle B.	956	19.5	80.5
	Grim, James	520	24.4	75.6
	Lippman, Daniel	660	25.6	74.4
	Chapman, Kevin J.	791	26.8	73.2
	Josephson, Kenneth	126	32.5	67.5
	Karden, Stuart F.	142	43	57
	Ortiz-Segura, Rafael B.	1298	48.3	51.7
	Ghartey, Victoria L.	1327	54	46
	Padgett, Gail B.	127	74.8	25.2
Philadelphia	Malloy, Rosalind K.	534	43.3	56.7
	Mills, Miriam K.	452	53.1	46.9
	Honeyman, Charles M.	386	67.1	32.9
Phoenix	Hollis, Wendell A.	248	29.8	70.2
	Freerks, LaMonte S.	317	61.5	38.5
	Richardson, John W.	180	76.1	23.9
Portland	Sloan, Andrea H.	105	38.1	61.9
	Bennett, Michael H.	519	39.7	60.3
San Antonio	Burkholder, Gary D.	304	11.8	88.2
	Conley de Castro, Susan E.	161	29.8	70.2
	McPhaul, Glenn P.	251	44.6	55.4
	Carte, John D.	181	55.8	44.2
	Zuniga, Bertha A.	350	60.9	39.1
	Burkhart, Margaret D.	103	67	33
San Diego	Ipema, Henry P., Jr.	200	48.5	51.5
	Bartolomei, Richard J., Jr	201	56.2	43.8
	Bagley, Kenneth A.	171	62.6	37.4
	Renner, Renee L.	342	64.6	35.4
	Atenaide, Anthony M.	291	64.6	35.4
	Fernandez, Ignacio P.	319	65.5	34.5
	DePaolo, Zsa Zsa	394	67.3	32.7
	Williams, John C.	164	75	25
San Francisco	Murry, Anthony S.	341	6.7	93.3
	Yamaguchi, Michael J.	238	15.1	84.9
	Simpson, Brian H.	123	22	78
	Stockton, Bette Kane	499	31.9	68.1
	Yeargin, Robert	545	39.8	60.2
	Proctor, George W.	132	47.7	52.3
	DiCostanzo, Lawrence N.	408	48	52
	Teeter, Marilyn J.	527	48.2	51.8
	Phillips, Beverley M.	122	48.4	51.6
	Griswold, Stephen S.	313	49.8	50.2
	Webber, Polly A.	706	49.9	50.1
	Hayward, Miriam R.	498	50	50
	Tue, Phan-Quang	521	50.3	49.7
	Maggard, Robert P.	269	55.4	44.6
	Hoogasian, Amy C.	106	58.5	41.5
	King, Carol A.	485	59	41
	Daw, Alison E.	123	60.2	39.8
	Lyons, Joren	163	62	38
	Marks, Dana Leigh	614	62.1	37.9
	Geisse, Loreto S.	536	63.8	36.2
	Ramirez, Laura L.	588	67.2	32.8
Seattle	Kandler, Edward R.	931	37.6	62.4
	Defonzo, Paul A.	331	40.8	59.2
	Josephson, Kenneth	1858	41.2	58.8
Tacoma	Fitting, Tammy L.	248	19	81
	Scala, Theresa M.	145	33.8	66.2
	Allred, Keith J.	102	48	52
West Valley	Nixon, William L.	215	35.8	64.2
	Pead, Dustin B.	153	40.5	59.5
York	Arthur, Andrew R.	214	9.8	90.2
	Durling, Walter A.	222	25.2	74.8